A monumental change to the rule books of Major League Baseball took effect on Aug. 28, 2008, when instant replay was approved to be used in regular-season play.
Six days later on Sept. 3, replay debuted: With the Yankees holding a ninth-inning lead in Tampa Bay, Alex Rodriguez hit a shot to left field that was called a homer, but then met with opposition by Rays manager Joe Maddon. The umpires conferred, checked the footage and upheld the ruling.
On Sept. 19, replay was again required at Tropicana Field, and this time, it produced the first overturned call on a controversial Carlos Pena drive to right field. Because a spectator reached out to catch the ball, the initial ruling was a ground-rule double due to fan interference. However, Maddon wound up with the call in his favor, as it was determined that Pena's blast had cleared the wall, regardless of the fan's actions.
Altogether, instant replay has been used 123 times since its introduction, with 48 of those instances resulting in overturned calls. Below is a chart that details the times when instant replay was required, the players involved and the final ruling:
Date | Game | Inn. | Pitcher | Batter | Original ruling | Replay ruling | Crew chief | Story | Video |
| 9/3/08 | NYY-TB | 9 | Troy Percival | Alex Rodriguez | HR | HR | Charlie Reliford | Story | Video |
| 9/9/08 | PIT-HOU | 6 | Jesse Chavez | Hunter Pence | 2B | 2B | Tim Welke | Story | Video |
| 9/19/08 | MIN-TB | 4 | Boof Bonser | Carlos Pena | Fan int. | HR | Gerry Davis | Story | Video |
| 9/23/08 | CIN-HOU | 7 | Chris Sampson | Joey Votto | 1B | 1B | Gary Darling | Story | Video |
| 9/24/08 | LAA-SEA | 5 | Felix Hernandez | Vlad Guerrero | Foul | Foul | Tim Welke | Story | Video |
| 9/26/08 | WSH-PHI | 6 | Joe Blanton | Kory Casto | HR | HR | Mike Reilly | Story | Video |
| 9/26/08 | LAD-SF | 6 | Scott Proctor | Bengie Molina | In play | HR | Tim Welke | Story | Video |
| 4/19/09 | CLE-NYY | 7 | Jensen Lewis | Jorge Posada | HR | HR | Jerry Crawford | Story | Video |
| 4/22/09 | OAK-NYY | 2 | CC Sabathia | Kurt Suzuki | HR | HR | Gerry Davis | Story | Video |
| 4/24/09 | SF-ARI | 3 | Tim Lincecum | Eric Byrnes | 2B | 2B | Jerry Crawford | Story | Video |
| 4/25/09 | SEA-LAA | 3 | Carlos Silva | Gary Matthews | Fan int. | Fan int. | Tim McLelland | Story | Video |
| 4/29/09 | FLA-NYM | 6 | Josh Johnson | Fernando Tatis | HR | HR | Dale Scott | Story | Video |
| 5/13/09 | STL-PIT | 1 | Joel Pineiro | Adam LaRoche | HR | 2B | Randy Marsh | Story | Video |
| 5/13/09 | FLA-MIL | 6 | Braden Looper | Ross Gload | HR | Foul | Gary Darling | Story | Video |
| 5/23/09 | TEX-HOU | 1 | Scott Feldman | Miguel Tejada | HR | HR | Gary Cederstrom | Story | Video |
| 5/23/09 | NYM-BOS | 9 | Jonathan Papelbon | Omir Santos | In play | HR | Joe West | Story | Video |
| 5/24/09 | NYM-BOS | 5 | Tim Redding | Kevin Youkilis | Foul | Foul | Joe West | Story | Video |
| 5/25/09 | WSH-NYM | 6 | John Lannan | Gary Sheffield | HR | HR | Larry Vanover | Story | Video |
| 5/27/09 | WSH-NYM | 6 | Jordan Zimmermann | Daniel Murphy | 2B | HR | Larry Vanover | Story | Video |
| 5/28/09 | TB-CLE | 6 | Jensen Lewis | Manny Aybar | HR | HR | Tim Welke | Story | Video |
| 6/03/09 | BAL-SEA | 1 | Jason Vargas | Aubrey Huff | HR | Foul | Ed Montague | Story | Video |
| 6/04/09 | BOS-DET | 6 | Tim Wakefield | Jeff Larish | Foul | Foul | Tim Tschida | Story | Video |
| 6/06/09 | TEX-BOS | 2 | Derek Holland | Mike Lowell | 2B | HR | Jeff Kellogg | Story | Video |
| 6/09/09 | SEA-BAL | 1 | Jason Vargas | Melvin Mora | HR | Out | Gary Cederstrom | Story | Video |
| 6/09/09 | LAA-TB | 5 | James Shields | Howard Kendrick | 3B | 3B | Jeff Kellogg | Story | Video |
| 6/10/09 | PIT-ATL | 6 | Jeff Karstens | Brian McCann | 2B | 2B | Dana DeMuth | Story | Video |
| 6/13/09 | CIN-KC | 6 | Bronson Arroyo | Billy Butler | Foul | Foul | Jerry Layne | Story | Video |
| 6/19/09 | MIL-DET | 3 | Braden Looper | Miguel Cabrera | 1B | HR | Dale Scott | Story | Video |
| 6/19/09 | MIL-DET | 4 | Braden Looper | Dusty Ryan | HR | 2B | Dale Scott | Story | Video |
| 6/21/09 | LAD-LAA | 8 | John Lackey | James Loney | HR | HR | Tim Tschida | Story | Video |
| 6/25/09 | PHI-TB | 8 | Jack Taschner | Pat Burrell | GR 2B | GR 2B | Gary Cederstrom | Story | Video |
| 7/01/09 | SEA-NYY | 5 | Jarrod Washburn | Melky Cabrera | HR | HR | Dale Scott | Story | Video |
| 7/03/09 | HOU-SF | 2 | Felipe Paulino | Travis Ishikawa | 2B | HR | Randy Marsh | Story | Video |
| 7/06/09 | PIT-HOU | 1 | Virgil Vasquez | Geoff Blum | 3B | 3B | Gerry Davis | Story | Video |
| 7/12/09 | WAS-HOU | 4 | Jordan Zimmermann | Carlos Lee | 2B | 2B | Brian O'Nora | Story | Video |
| 7/17/09 | LAA-OAK | 2 | Trevor Cahill | Kendry Morales | HR | HR | Jerry Layne | Story | Video |
| 7/19/09 | MIN-TEX | 4 | Francisco Liriano | Andruw Jones | HR | Foul | Gary Cederstrom | Story | Video |
| 7/20/09 | CIN-LAD | 4 | Jason Schmidt | Willy Taveras | 3B | 3B | Ed Montague | Story | Video |
| 7/22/09 | MIL-PIT | 4 | Jeff Suppan | Ryan Doumit | 2B | HR | Wally Bell | Story | Video |
| 7/29/09 | WAS-MIL | 3 | Garret Mock | Ryan Braun | HR | 3B | Joe West | Story | Video |
| 7/29/09 | PHI-ARI | 8 | Tyler Walker | Gerardo Parra | 2B | 2B | Derryl Cousins | Story | Video |
| 7/31/09 | BOS-BAL | 3 | John Smoltz | Nolan Reimold | HR | HR | Jeff Kellogg | Story | Video |
| 8/02/09 | LAA-MIN | 8 | Shane Loux | Joe Mauer | 2B | 2B | Gerry Davis | Story | Video |
| 8/10/09 | CHC-COL | 2 | Esmailin Caridad | Troy Tulowitzki | Foul | Foul | Bob Davidson | Story | Video |
| 8/11/09 | TOR-NYY | 8 | Jesse Carlson | Jorge Posada | HR | HR | Joe West | Story | Video |
| 8/11/09 | PHI-CHC | 9 | Angel Guzman | Carlos Ruiz | HR | Foul | Dale Scott | Story | Video |
| 8/14/09 | NYA-SEA | 2 | Ryan Rowland-Smith | Jorge Posada | 2B | 2B | Gerry Davis | Story | Video |
| 8/16/09 | HOU-MIL | 6 | Braden Looper | Hunter Pence | HR | Foul | Tim Welke | Story | Video |
| 8/20/09 | MIN-TEX | 6 | Bob Keppel | Michael Young | 2B | 2B | Dale Scott | Story | Video |
| 8/25/09 | TEX-NYY | 4 | Kevin Millwood | Robinson Cano | HR | HR | Bob Davidson | Story | Video |
| 8/25/09 | DET-LAA | 6 | John Lackey | Curtis Granderson | 3B | 3B | Mark Carlson | Story | Video |
| 8/26/09 | OAK-SEA | 6 | Luke French | Jack Cust | Foul | Foul | Mike Winters | Story | Video |
| 8/28/09 | OAK-LAA | 6 | Craig Breslow | Kendry Morales | Foul | Foul | Tim McClelland | Story | Video |
| 8/31/09 | PIT-CIN | 5 | Paul Maholm | Brandon Phillips | HR | Foul | Rick Reed | Story | Video |
| 9/05/09 | NYY-TOR | 2 | Andy Pettitte | Randy Ruiz | HR | Foul | Tim Tschida | Story | Video |
| 9/10/09 | DET-KC | 8 | Eddie Bonine | Brayan Pena | HR | HR | Wally Bell | Story | Video |
| 9/10/09 | ATL-HOU | 3 | Derek Lowe | Lance Berkman | HR | HR | Gary Darling | Story | Video |
| 9/12/09 | SEA-TEX | 5 | Brandon Morrow | Chris Davis | HR | 2B | Gary Cederstrom | Story | Video |
| 9/22/09 | SF-ARI | 3 | Matt Cain | Gerardo Parra | HR | 2B | Wally Bell | Story | Video |
| 9/23/09 | SF-ARI | 6 | Jonathan Sanchez | Rusty Ryal | 3B | 3B | Wally Bell | Story | Video |
| 9/27/09 | SD-ARI | 8 | Edward Mujica | Chad Tracy | HR | HR | Rick Reed | Story | Video |
| 9/29/09 | ARI-SF | 4 | Jonathan Sanchez | Ryan Roberts | HR | 2B | Dana DeMuth | Story | Video |
| 9/30/09 | NYM-WAS | 2 | John Lannan | Jeff Francoeur | 2B | 2B | Wally Bell | Story | Video |
| 9/30/09 | HOU-PHI | 2 | Pedro Martinez | J.R. Towles | 2B | HR | Tim Tschida | Story | Video |
| 10/31/09 | NYA-PHI | 4 | Cole Hamels | Alex Rodriguez | 2B | HR | Gerry Davis | Story | Video |
| 4/6/10 | SF-HOU | 6 | Barry Zito | Jeff Keppinger | 2B | 2B | Tim Welke | Story | Video |
| 4/11/10 | WAS-NYM | 1 | Johan Santana | Josh Willingham | 3B | HR | Derryl Cousins | Story | Video |
| 4/12/10 | BOS-MIN | 1 | Carl Pavano | Mike Cameron | Foul | Foul | Tim Tschida | Story | Video |
| 4/13/10 | CIN-FLA | 2 | Nate Robertson | Jay Bruce | HR | Foul | Jeff Kellogg | Story | Video |
| 4/20/10 | CLE-MIN | 5 | Kevin Slowey | Austin Kearns | 2B | 2B | Tim Tschida | Story | Video |
| 4/23/10 | CHC-MIL | 1 | Ryan Dempster | Prince Fielder | 2B | 2B | John Hirschbeck | Story | Video |
| 5/3/10 | STL-PHI | 1 | Jaime Garcia | Chase Utley | Foul | Foul | Tim McClelland | Story | Video |
| 5/4/10 | NYM-CIN | 8 | Fernando Nieve | Scott Rolen | HR | HR | Tim Welke | Story | Video |
| 5/7/10 | CHC-CIN | 8 | Carlos Fisher | Marlon Byrd | 2B | 2B | Jerry Layne | Story | Video |
| 5/10/10 | TOR-BOS | 2 | John Lackey | Alex Gonzalez | 2B | 2B | Dale Scott | Story | Video |
| 5/11/10 | WAS-NYM | 8 | Miguel Batista | Ike Davis | Foul | Foul | John Hirschbeck | Story | Video |
| 5/16/10 | TEX-TOR | 4 | Colby Lewis | John Buck | Double | Double | Mike Estabrook | Story | Video |
| 5/18/10 | CWS-DET | 6 | Freddy Garcia | Brandon Inge | HR | Foul | Dale Scott | Story | Video |
| 5/19/10 | MIN-BOS | 4 | Scott Baker | David Ortiz | Triple | HR | Jerry Layne | Story | Video |
| 5/23/10 | NYY-NYM | 7 | Johan Santana | Francisco Cervelli | Single | Single | Derryl Cousins | Story | Video |
| 5/28/10 | TEX-MIN | 4 | Kevin Slowey | Michael Young | Homer | Foul | Brian Gorman | Story | Video |
| 5/28/10 | LAD-COL | 4 | Carlos Monasterios | Clint Barmes | Homer | Homer | Dale Scott | Story | Video |
| 6/1/10 | LAA-KC | 6 | Brian Bannister | Hideki Matsui | Double | Double | Mike Winters | Story | Video |
| 6/3/10 | OAK-BOS | 8 | Jerry Blevins | Marco Scutaro | Home run | Home run | Dana DeMuth | Story | Video |
| 6/5/10 | BOS-BAL | 6 | Jeremy Guthrie | Marco Scutaro | Foul | Foul | Wally Bell | Story | Video |
| 6/8/10 | SD-NYM | 8 | Clayton Richard | Jose Reyes | Double | Home run | Tim Welke | Story | Video |
| 6/16/10 | SEA-STL | 4 | Jason Vargas | Albert Pujols | 2B | 2B | Gary Cederstrom | Story | Video |
| 7/1/10 | NYM-WAS | 5 | Johan Santana | Ian Desmond | 2B | 2B | Tim Welke | Story | Video |
| 7/3/10 | NYM-WAS | 9 | Francisco Rodriguez | Adam Dunn | 2B | 2B | Tim Welke | Story | Video |
| 7/3/10 | PHI-PIT | 4 | Paul Maholm | Jayson Werth | 2B | 2B | Brian O'Nora | Story | Video |
| 7/3/10 | BAL-BOS | 9 | Robert Manuel | Jake Fox | 2B | HR | Tim McClelland | Story | Video |
| 7/5/10 | CLE-TEX | 7 | Joe Smith | Nelson Cruz | HR | Foul | Tim Tschida | Story | Video |
| 7/7/10 | KC-SEA | 9 | Chad Cordero | Billy Butler | 2B | HR | Brian Gorman | Story | Video |
| 7/10/10 | SF-WAS | 9 | Miguel Batista | Buster Posey | 2B | HR | Derryl Cousins | Story | Video |
| 7/16/10 | COL-CIN | 8 | Bronson Arroyo | Miguel Olivo | HR | HR | Tom Hallion | Story | Video |
| 7/24/10 | TB-CLE | 5 | Mitch Talbot | Ben Zobrist | 3B | HR | Mike Everitt | Story | Video |
| 7/26/10 | FLA-SF | 7 | Taylor Tankersley | Aaron Rowand | HR | HR | Tom Hallion | Story | Video |
| 7/26/10 | BOS-LAA | 8 | Scott Atchison | Hideki Matsui | HR | HR | John Hirschbeck | Story | Video |
| 7/30/10 | SEA-MIN | 5 | Doug Fister | Alexi Casilla | 3B | HR | Tom Hallion | Story | Video |
| 8/1/10 | SEA-MIN | 2 | Francisco Liriano | Josh Wilson | Foul | Foul | Tom Hallion | Story | Video |
| 8/5/10 | PHI-FLA | 10 | Will Ohman | Ben Francisco | Foul | Foul | Tim Tschida | Story | Video |
| 8/6/10 | COL-PIT | 9 | Joel Hanrahan | Dexter Fowler | HR | 3B | Mike Reilly | Story | Video |
| 8/6/10 | MIN-CLE | 9 | Chris Perez | Jim Thome | 2B | 2B | Gerry Davis | Story | Video |
| 8/7/10 | COL-PIT | 10 | Huston Street | Andrew McCutchen | HR | 2B | Mike Reilly | Story | Video |
| 8/12/10 | FLA-WAS | 2 | Livan Hernandez | Mike Stanton | 3B | HR | Jerry Layne | Story | Video |
| 8/13/10 | PHI-NYM | 5 | Cole Hamels | Mike Hessman | HR | 3B | Tom Hallion | Story | Video |
| 8/16/10 | TEX-TB | 7 | David Price | Bengie Molina | 2B | 2B | Dale Scott | Story | Video |
| 8/23/10 | MIN-TEX | 1 | Nick Blackburn | David Murphy | 3B | 3B | Derryl Cousins | Story | Video |
| 8/25/10 | ARI-SD | 1 | Wade LeBlanc | Stephen Drew | 2B | HR | Brian Gorman | Story | Video |
| 8/29/10 | FLA-ATL | 9 | Leo Nunez | Brian McCann | 2B | HR | Tim McClelland | Story | Video |
| 9/02/10 | DET-MIN | 2 | Scott Baker | Austin Jackson | 3B | 3B | Dan Bellino | Story | Video |
| 9/04/10 | COL-SD | 1 | Jason Hammel | Adrian Gonzalez | 2B | 2B | Gary Darling | Story | Video |
| 9/04/10 | TB-BAL | 5 | James Shields | Luke Scott | 2B | 2B | Tim Welke | Story | Video |
| 9/06/10 | CWS-DET | 8 | Chris Sale | Brandon Inge | HR | Foul | Brian Gorman | Story | Video |
| 9/07/10 | TEX-TOR | 2 | Scott Feldman | John Buck | 2B | HR | Tom Hallion | Story | Video |
| 9/07/10 | CLE-LAA | 6 | Trevor Bell | Travis Hafner | HR | HR | Joe West | Story | Video |
| 9/14/10 | DET-TEX | 4 | Jeremy Bonderman | David Murphy | HR | HR | Brian Runge | Story | Video |
| 9/15/10 | DET-TEX | 1 | Colby Lewis | Ryan Rayburn | 2B | 2B | Jerry Layne | Story | Video |
| 9/20/10 | KC-DET | 6 | Zack Greinke | Will Rhymes | 3B | HR | Dale Scott | Story | Video |
| 9/28/10 | OAK-LAA | 7 | Dallas Braden | Peter Bourjos | HR | Foul | Dana DeMuth | Story | Video |
| 10/03/10 | PIT-FLA | 6 | Brian Burres | Wes Helms | HR | 2B | Joe West | Story | Video |
| 10/10/10 | PHI-CIN | 5 | Johnny Cueto | Chase Utley | HR | HR | John Hirschbeck | Story | Video |
| 10/19/10 | TEX-NYY | 2 | Tommy Hunter | Lance Berkman | HR | Foul | Gerry Davis | Story | Video |
This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.
